Took a brisket class in Fort Worth last month, and the wrap thing has me torn
I paid $150 for a day class in Fort Worth last month, and the pitmaster there wraps in butcher paper at 165 and swears peach paper beats foil for bark. But my buddy back in Lubbock wraps in foil with a splash of beef broth and his flats come out juicier than anything I turn out. When I tried the paper method at home on a 12 pound packer, the bark was great but the flat dried out on me by hour 10. So which is it: paper for bark and foil for moisture, or is that just what two guys in different towns happen to do? Curious what you all run on a packer that size.
Sounds like the stall is the real problem, not the wrap. Next time try letting it ride to 170-175 before you wrap, gives the flat more time to render and the paper won't dry it out as fast.