28
Found my great-grandma's 1923 recipe book in the attic and compared her handwritten notes to the typed copy my aunt made.
Her notes in the margins about adding a pinch of nutmeg to the apple pie and letting the dough rest 'until it feels like a baby's cheek' made the pies taste like home, while the typed version just gave cold measurements and times.
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
stella2791mo ago
That line about the dough feeling like a baby's cheek is EVERYTHING. It's not just a recipe, it's a whole feeling. The typed version loses the soul, the little tricks that make it taste like her kitchen.
4
rodriguez.cora7d ago
Totally get what you mean, @stella279. It makes me wonder about the recipes that never got written down at all, the ones that only live in someone's hands. My aunt's pie crust method was just her saying "add enough water until it looks right," and you had to stand there and see what "right" was in her bowl.
10
riley551mo ago
Right? That's the whole magic of a handwritten recipe card. The stains and the little notes in the margin are the real ingredients. My grandma's cookie recipe just says "bake until done," and you had to watch her to learn that meant when the edges just barely turned gold. Typing it out turns it into a list, and the heart gets lost.
2