Update: switched from public reviews to a paid trial account in January, and my trust in ratings dropped fast
Back in January I opened a $500 practice account with a broker I had picked purely off a 4.6 star score on a review site. For 8 weeks the fills were fine, but the moment I moved to real money in March, my spread on EUR/USD jumped from 0.9 pips to 2.4 pips during the London open. I pulled their terms and found a clause about 'market conditions' that basically let them do it with no notice. Turns out most of those glowing reviews came from people who never traded past the demo. My real take now is that any broker review written inside 30 days is close to useless, so I only read ones with at least 6 months of account history behind them. What's your cutoff before you trust a review enough to open an account?