Loading…
19
Overheard someone say the ending was 'too clean' and now I can't stop thinking about it
Last week at a coffee shop in Portland, some guy was arguing that a popular novel wrapped up every loose thread perfectly and that made it weak. He said real trauma doesn't tie up in a bow, so why should fiction? I get it, messy endings feel more honest sometimes. But I've also cried harder at books where the character finally gets one small win after 300 pages of loss. Is a clean ending a cop-out or just hope we desperately need? Anyone else flip-flop on this after hearing someone else's take?
1 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In1 Comment
bennett.luna1mo ago
Standing in line at a coffee shop critiquing narrative structure is a bold move for someone who probably still has a tab open from 2019. But sure, let's all pretend our own lives have neat little arcs where the barista hands us a latte and suddenly everything makes sense. I've read both kinds, and honestly the tidy ones hit harder when real life is just a pile of unresolved nonsense. Maybe it's a cop-out, but I'll take a fictional win over my actual credit score any day.
1