Our club almost broke up over a 3 page short story in March
Back in March our group of 7 in Akron picked Ted Chiang's 'Exhalation' and got into a screaming match over whether the last page was hopeful or bleak. Half the room said the machine dying meant something good and the rest said it was the saddest thing they ever read, and two members quit over it, which felt insane for a short story. How do you all handle it when a book splits the group right down the middle, do you pick a lighter one next time or lean into the fight?