Our book club read 41 books in 2 years and I just counted the DNF pile
I tallied our club's reading list at the kitchen table and we finished 41 books since January 2023, but 9 of those got quit by half the group. Does your club log the quitters too, or does everyone just pretend they finished?
The shared doc idea is great and the no-explanation rule is the best part. I get why it felt mean at first, but leaving room for people to just log a quit without a speech takes all the pressure off. Our club has the same problem where a few people say they finished when they clearly didn't, and it makes the talks weird because you can't tell who actually read it. Tracking where people stopped sounds really useful too, since it shows if a book lost everyone at the same spot. Sorry your group had to deal with that fake-finisher stuff, it wears on you after a while. Keeping it simple and honest like you did seems like the fix.
The part about 9 books being quit by half the group is what got me, because that's a lot more than most clubs would admit to. We started keeping a shared doc a couple years back and just marked every book with who finished, who bailed, and where they stopped. It felt a little mean at first, but it actually helped us pick better books since we could see which ones everyone kept dropping. The one rule we made is nobody has to explain why they quit, they just log it. I mean it takes like ten seconds and it kills all the awkward "oh yeah I finished it" stuff at meetings. Maybe it's just me but the honesty made the club more fun, not less.