I finally got the group to settle on a pick after 3 meetings of arguing
Our club in Fort Wayne spent three straight meetings (about 4 hours total) stuck on picking the next book because everyone kept tossing out titles and nobody would budge. I set up a simple rule where each person brings 2 picks and we vote by secret ballot, and it went from a shouting match to done in 20 minutes. Has anyone else tried a voting system like this, or does it just kill the fun of arguing for your group?
Your club got things done fast and that is a real win, but I see the arguing part as the fun of a book club. The back and forth over titles is how people find out what each other likes, and you lose some of that when the ballot does the talking. My group tried strict voting once and it stopped the bickering, but it also stopped the good talks where someone talks you into a book you would never pick on your own. Your 2 picks rule is a smart fix for the endless tie ups, though I would keep the open talk before the secret vote so folks still get to make their case out loud. Twenty minutes is great, but a little friendly arguing is not always a bad thing.