Old timer told me to go easy on the quench oil temp, I ignored him
A guy at the Salem hammer-in, must be 70 now, said to bring 1050 oil up to 120 before dipping a blade or you'll get micro cracks. I thought he was being fussy, so I did my usual cold dunk on a 1084 chef knife and sure enough, a hairline appeared right at the edge. Has anyone else had a quench temperature tip that sounded like superstition but turned out to save the piece?
That "micro cracks" line made me dig into some old heat treating books, and a few of them say warm oil helps the steel cool at a steadier rate instead of shocking the edge. Cold oil pulls heat out so fast that thin sections can't keep up, which is where those tiny splits come from. Wish I'd read that before I wasted a good piece of 1084 last winter.