Chill your dough for 24 hours or bake it same day? My fridge test from March says a lot
I made the same chocolate chip cookie recipe two ways back in March, one batch straight into the oven and one batch sitting in the fridge for 24 hours, and the gap was bigger than I expected. Same flour, same butter, same oven at 350, and the chilled ones spread way less and came out thicker with a chewier middle. The same day ones looked fine but tasted flat and ran into each other on the sheet. My wife said the chilled batch tasted like a bakery cookie, and she does not hand out compliments to my baking often. Now I am stuck on which side I actually land on, because chilling means I have to plan a day ahead and some nights I just want cookies in 30 minutes. The other side of it is thin crispy edges, which the same day batch did deliver if that is your thing. So which camp are you in, plan ahead and chill or bake right away and deal with the spread?