Photo lab guy in Fresno critiqued my push processing, now I'm questioning the whole approach
Took a roll of HP5 pushed to 1600 into a lab in Fresno and the tech asked why I was pushing it instead of just shooting Delta 3200. He pointed at my negs and pointed out the blown highlights on every frame that had any window light in it. Now I'm stuck debating whether pushing is a real creative choice or just me being stubborn about one film stock. Part of me thinks there's no wrong answer here and part of me thinks he was right to call it out. Where do you all land on this?